Casey Nicewander, Insurance Agent | Liberty Mutual

Casey Nicewander

Comparion Insurance Agent

""Expert insurance advice from a member of your local community""

My local office

1411 Rose Street
La Crosse, WI, 54603
Book an appointment with me

About me

I'm a guy not too different from you. I'm a Christian, father, husband, son, friend, veteran, and bow hunter. I care about the needs of my family and my friends. I like to come alongside people to help them make wise and cost effective decisions to insure their loved ones. If you are like most people I meet, it's hard to know the rights steps and resources you need to protect the products you hold dear. I act as your personal coach to deliver quality insurance to protect you on some of your most challenging days. I love to get to know my clients and hear your personal story. If you would like to look for superior insurance coverage, cost effective solutions, or want a local agent, I'd love to connect with you over a great cup of coffee soon.
Follow me

Services:

  • Snowmobile Insurance
  • RV Insurances
  • Auto Insurance
  • Home Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Annuities
  • Renters Insurance
  • Motorcycle
  • Pet Insurance
  • Umbrella

Licensed in:

  • Minnesota
  • Wisconsin
  • Iowa
  • Illinois

Quote with Casey Nicewander

We're ready to offer personalized advice on your auto, home, life, or pet insurance needs.
Start your quote

Get claims help

File or manage your claim 24/7
Visit the Claims Center
Google Reviews
4.9 / 5
4.9 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
(30 Reviews)
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey was so helpful & so amazing!!!! Thank you for all the help. He exceeded exceptional customer service!!!! Thank you again Casey
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 11, 2023
Hi Keandria, I appreciate you sharing this positive review!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
one of the nicest guys i’ve met. walked me through everything perfectly and let me find a price that’s good for me
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 10, 2023
Hi Josh, that's great to hear! Thank you for sharing such a positive review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I learned about Casey from the team at Coulee Auto. At first I was skeptical but decided to let him look for options to our current Auto and homeowners policies we had with another company that we’ve been with for more than 30 years. Casey found policies with a highly reputable, well-established old company, that improved our coverage on our vehicles and our home, and saved us nearly a thousand dollars per year. To be honest, I was stunned. I never thought we would choose to leave the company we were with for so long. And as we waited for the computer to do it’s thing and policies to be confirmed and all the stuff going on, we had time to chat a bit. What a great guy, Casey is, a Marine Corps veteran, like myself. And even though I was out, probably before he was born, Marines are a brotherhood and we hit it off immediately. Bottom line, Casey is a good man providing an excellent service, easy to talk to without any pressure. I would highly recommend Casey for any of your insurance needs!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 6, 2023
Todd, I am so glad you enjoyed your experience and grateful for your kind words. Thank you for taking the time to leave such a detailed review. You made my day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I cannot say enough about Casey and his stellar service! He has won our trust and business for many years to come! Definitely recommend!!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 11, 2022
Thank you for your positive review, Sara! This kind of feedback motivates us to continue exceeding quality standards.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey was super helpful with switching over our policies and saved us $300!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 4, 2022
Hi Anna, that's great to hear! I’m thrilled that you are satisfied with our services.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey has been my agent for 2 years now and is a pleasure to do business with. His efficiency, responsiveness and ability to understand the needs of his clients are reasons why I will continue to have Casey as my agent for many years to come!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 2, 2022
Hi, Trista! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
He explained everything to me to make sure that this is the coverage that I want
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 2, 2022
Hi Tommy, thanks for leaving such a positive review!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey helped me and my wife save over $1000 a year on our insurance premiums, while giving me better coverage than I originally had! Prompt service. Clear communication. Took the time to get to know my situation. Obvious care for what he does. It doesn’t get better than that!
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 5, 2022
We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the work we put in every day. Thanks for your kind words, Cam!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey was referred to me by a friend when I was really struggling to get decent coverage. He has been nothing short of amazing since I started working with him. Very professional and informative. He has helped me add cars and people and re work my insurance time and time again. Very pleased with his service!
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 23, 2022
We can’t thank you enough for your kind words Tristen. Your review means a lot to us and lets us know we’re on the right track!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 19, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
It was a very good experience, knowledgeable and he made it very easy to make the decision to change companies.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 14, 2022
Debbie, thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey is professional & friendly. Always helpful & prompt in all he does. We much appreciate him.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 7, 2022
We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the work we put in every day. Thanks for your kind words, Patricia!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 7, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Paul!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I've worked with Casey the past couple years, he is so awesome and is always there for me when i call for my insurance needs. Always tries to find me the best deals to save me money. I would highly recommend him for all your insurance needs.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 7, 2022
Your review means a lot to us and lets us know we’re on the right track! We appreciate you recommending our services in your comments and we're happy to hear that you had a wonderful customer experience. Thanks Jenny!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
August 31, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Susie!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
August 19, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Jared!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
It was time for me to renew my policy and I searched my email to get in touch with Casey. Great customer service. Very friendly, professional, helpful and knowledgeable. Does his best to get you the best deals. Quick response. He's My agent.
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 27, 2022
Wow, we were blown away by your positive words. We really appreciate the time you took to write such a detailed review! Thank you Kimberly!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Fantastic agent. Works wonderfully, responds as soon as he is able, and solves problems!
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 20, 2022
Hi Britney, thanks for leaving such a positive review!
4 out of 5
4 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Empty
A little pushy for wanting to sign up new customers.
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Hi Lynda Decker, Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey did a terrific job of helping me find the best quote for my home and auto insurance and was also very accommodating in all of my requests to get numbers on the different coverage options. Highly recommended!
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Chris Bennett, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
We switched to Liberty a little over a year ago. Casey walked us through each step of the transition process to make it easy. He is professional and helpful for all our questions. We highly recommend Casey for your auto, boat, home, and all your insurance needs! Charles & Deedee Dart
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Deedee Dart, we are so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey has always called us back quickly and with the answers we need. From what I see, he’s been our hardest working insurance agent. He’s always looking to serve others above himself, even during deer season!
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the work we put in every day. Thanks for your kind words, Tom LaLond!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey is super responsive and has really taken care of us as we have changed/added several automobiles the past few years. I'd recommend giving him a chance to earn your business - I don't think he'll let you down!
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Derek Mueller. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Anthony & Ashley Hainzinger!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey has gone above and beyond with the service he has provided. Always working to give you the best value for your money!
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Jon Cuccio, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Amber Knutson!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Casey is awesome and a great insurance agent! He is personable and professional. I was in a tricky situation and Casey worked hard at getting me the best price possible without compromising too much on coverage. If you are looking for a new agent or comparing quotes, contacting Casey would be a good choice!
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Linda Sweek, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
4 out of 5
4 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Empty
After being recommended to Casey through a friend I called and he got back to me very quick and compared prices for me getting me the best deal. I found him to be professional and courteous.
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Thank you, Paul Schwartz!
4 out of 5
4 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Empty
Casey has been great helping my family navigate the often confusing world of insurance. He is incredibly personable and has always given my wife and me fast and pertinent responses to our questions.
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Craig Wotruba, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Charisma Starks!
Write a Review
Comparion Reviews
5 / 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
(3 Reviews)
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Great customer service, fast at getting you the services you need and going above and beyond to make sure your needs are met.
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 13, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Cindy W.. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Feedback
Response from Comparion Insurance
May 31, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
My wife and I were shopping for better insurance rates. Casey Nicewander helped us bundle our insurance coverages and saved us a lot of money over what we had been paying with another company. We appreciate the professional service we received from you Casey! Thank you!
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 21, 2022
Laine L, we are so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business!
Write a Review

Our insurance partners

Did you know Comparion agents offer insurance from Liberty Mutual and many other companies? Agents can quote trusted insurance partners with products that cover your family, income and assets like a home, car, boat or jewelry. Our mission is to help you find the right insurance coverage at affordable rates.

Our key partners are listed below. We also offer dozens of other national and regional insurance companies depending on where you live.

  • Safeco Insurance
  • American Modern Insurance
  • Homesite Insurance
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • National General Insurance
  • Protective Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • rli
  • Travelers Insurance

Frequently asked questions

©2023 Comparion Insurance Agency, A Liberty Mutual Company - 175 Berkeley Street, Boston, MA 02116. The materials herein are for informational purposes only. All statements made are subject to provisions, exclusions, conditions, and limitations of the applicable insurance policy. Coverages and features not available in all states. Eligibility is subject to meeting applicable underwriting criteria. Learn more about our privacy policy at libertymutual.com/privacy.
Comparion is an Equal Opportunity Employer and an Equal Housing Insurer.