Katelyn McCarty, Insurance Agent | Liberty Mutual

Katelyn McCarty

Comparion Insurance Agent

"Expert insurance advice from a member of your local community"

My office

12444 Powerscourt Dr
Ste 100
Saint Louis, MO, 63131
Get directionsBook an appointment with me

About me

* Graduated from University of Missouri\-St. Louis with a degree in Criminology \& Criminal Justice * Serving clients in Oakville, MO; Greater St. Louis Area Illinois * Active member of Ladies Ancient Order of Hibernians * I help my clients by providing the expert advice needed to make informed insurance decisions * I work personally with my clients to recommend coverage levels and options customized for each life\-stage


  • Local insurance agent
  • Insurance agency
  • Insurance consultant
  • Insurance expert
  • Insurance coverage
  • Asset protection
  • Life insurance agent
  • Life insurance consultant
  • Annuity consultant
  • 401k consultant

Licensed in:

  • Illinois
  • Missouri


8:30am - 5:30pm
8:30am - 5:30pm
8:30am - 5:30pm
8:30am - 5:30pm
8:30am - 5:30pm

Quote with Katelyn McCarty

We're ready to offer personalized advice on your auto, home, life, or pet insurance needs.
Start your quote

Get claims help

File or manage your claim 24/7
Visit the Claims Center
Google Reviews
No reviews yet
Write a Review
Comparion Reviews
1 / 5
1 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar EmptyStar EmptyStar EmptyStar Empty
(1 Reviews)
1 out of 5
1 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar EmptyStar EmptyStar EmptyStar Empty
Katie has not been responsive or helpful with our auto insurance. We needed to file a claim and she was not knowledgeable about the process and did not seem to be able to assist in the process. She would say that she was not a claims adjuster and was not aware of the process. She never helped adjust our coverage to account for the loss of a vehicle and updating for the new vehicle. When we contact her she says she never talked to us about the accident or doesn't remember talking to us about the accident or claim. She is rude and short on the phone. She seems put off or like we are bothering her anytime we call. She has been the worst representative. I would not suggest or recommend working with her as she does not seem to respect or even want to work with clients. It seems like she only wants a paycheck but not to do any of the leg work to help clients.
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 21, 2022
Here at Liberty Mutual, we want to make sure we are connecting you with the appropriate teams to best address your concerns and needs. This is a local sales office. If you’d like to speak with a claims specialist, please call 800-225-2467.
Write a Review

Our insurance partners

Did you know Comparion agents offer insurance from Liberty Mutual and many other companies? Agents can quote trusted insurance partners with products that cover your family, income and assets like a home, car, boat or jewelry. Our mission is to help you find the right insurance coverage at affordable rates.

Our key partners are listed below. We also offer dozens of other national and regional insurance companies depending on where you live.

  • Safeco Insurance
  • American Modern Insurance
  • Homesite Insurance
  • Nationwide Insurance
  • National General Insurance
  • Protective Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • rli
  • Travelers Insurance

Frequently asked questions

About Comparion Insurance Agency in Saint Louis, MO

Local sales agents serving customers in Saint Louis, MO. We're launching Comparion Insurance Agency: A Liberty Mutual Company to help consumers and small businesses get the expert advice they need to find the right insurance policy. Comparion agents will help you find personalized coverage to fit your budget - offering options from Liberty Mutual and many other national and regional insurance companies.
Learn more about us
©2023 Comparion Insurance Agency, A Liberty Mutual Company - 175 Berkeley Street, Boston, MA 02116. The materials herein are for informational purposes only. All statements made are subject to provisions, exclusions, conditions, and limitations of the applicable insurance policy. Coverages and features not available in all states. Eligibility is subject to meeting applicable underwriting criteria. Learn more about our privacy policy at libertymutual.com/privacy.
Comparion is an Equal Opportunity Employer and an Equal Housing Insurer.