Comparion Insurance Agency

I work with Mr. Andrew Hartman for a wide variety of insurance needs, and he has never disappointed me. He's knowledge and effective, and I'll return to him every time I need something new.

Caroline Cowden is a knowledgeable agent who helped me walk through my insurance options! I’ll be using her for all my insurance needs from now on! She is great to work with!

I had the pleasure of working with Caroline Cowden and she was so responsive and helpful! Thank you!

I have been with Amber for over 5 years and she is the definition of a professional. She is always ready to help with anything I may put in front of her and I always feel like a priority. With Amber I know that my car and home are in great hands!

Great company, great agents! I highly recommend Caroline Cowden. She couldn’t be more helpful, professional and knowledgeable about insurance.

Caroline Cowden was so helpful with my insurance needs. She answered my questions efficiently and helped to get me a great rate.

Caroline Cowden = 2 Thumbs UP. I personally live a fairly 'rock-n-roll' lifestyle and for years I have been having trouble finding life insurance that could adequately give me the coverage I needed...while still not costing me an arm and a leg! That's when Caroline stepped in and saved the day. In fact, I was so impressed with her attention to detail I ended up getting the full auto, life and home bundle!

Holly is my go to insurance agent! She always answers my calls if not immediately, she calls me right back. Her positivity and can do attitude make even stressful situations feel like just another day in the life. Thank you Holly!

The best in the business. Amber and her team are unparalleled and have made insurance for both my car and my home super easy.

My experience with Caroline Cowden and her company has been awesome ! She responded to my !%^%%!! situation immediately with fantastic results. I would recommend her to anyone.

Caroline Cowden was a Godsend. With a house full of “inexperienced drivers”, our rates were skyrocketing- ESPECIALLY since their only REAL experience is speeding tickets. Bundling my home and auto, and adding an umbrella policy for when the moronic neighbor’s kids break their neck on our trampoline or drown in the hot tub lets me sleep at night. She was very diligent in making sure we were with the right carriers and I appreciate her professionalism and dedication to the task.

I was intimidated and clueless about where to start with insurance, and Caroline went above and beyond to help answer all my questions. She was incredibly knowledgeable and walked me through every step. Highly recommend Caroline for all your insurance needs!

When my youngest daughter finally turned 21, I thought it was high time for her to get off the family plan and have her find insurance coverage of her own. She stumbled upon Comparion and WOW have I been impressed! Her agent, Caroline Cowden, walked her through the process and made it simple, clear and AFFORDABLE! I will be sure to recommend her services to all my fellow empty-nesters seeking to set their birdies free! Thanks, Caroline!

Caroline Cowden is an amazing agent! She looked at and compared current policies to see how she could save me money. She is dedicated, determined, and trustworthy. If you work with Caroline, you won’t be disappointed!

Caroline Cowden is so personable and efficient! Not only was she friendly, but she was also knowledgeable & helpful!

Caroline Cowden was a pleasure to work with! She was efficient and knowledgeable. I would absolutely recommend her!

Amber Preziosi is a great insurance professional. Highly recommend. She insures my auto, home, pet, life and umbrella.

I have worked with Gabby Devine for years. She is by far the kindest most knowledgeable agent we have ever had I can't imagine her not protecting us. She is a true asset!

Susan Ramsden was absolutely spectacular!!! I went with Susan for renters insurance and she was quick to find me exactly what I needed at a rate I was happy with!!! If your looking for insurance your in the right spot!!!

Contacted Comparion for a quote to compare my current insurance with what might be a more economical way to go. Was hesitant to try Comparion as it is a new company and I was unfamiliar with what they had to offer. Caroline Cowden was the representative I worked with and was thrilled with my experience. She was informative, responsive, and knowledgeable. Caroline answered all my questions and concerns and came up with an excellent plan for me. She made me a believer. I would highly recommend Comparion and Caroline, in particular!

Caroline Cowden is a rockstar. So happy to have her as a rep.

Caroline Cowden was very efficient and helpful with my insurance needs. She had the most competitive rates and it was a joy working with her!

I have been very impressed with Caroline Cowden - her professionalism, work ethic and deep insurance expertise are unmatched in the industry! Would 100% recommend.

Caroline Cowden is my savior. She is kind, intelligent, and makes the process seamless. My life would not be together without her!

Caroline Cowden is so easy to talk to and always willing to help. I am so grateful to have been connected to her. She has an easy way about her that makes everyone comfortable!

Amber is the best! She’s quick to respond, answer any questions you have, and in the kindest way! She has even gone out of her way to find out an answer to a question I had on her day off. She goes above and beyond!!

Great service and friendly people, Lauren Semelsberger has helped me with all my insurance needs and really takes the time to try and understand what a customer is looking for and helping them get a policy that best fits an individual's needs.

Amber is AMAZING! She is so helpful and nice and I wouldn’t want to work with anyone else.

I am beyond grateful to have Amber Preziosi as my local insurance agent! She is so professional, thorough, knowledgeable, and genuinely cares for her clients. I know she is always working to find me the best coverage at the best rates, and I really appreciate her taking the time to answer all of my questions and provide many different quotes for me to compare. Thank you, Amber!

Wow. I was so impressed with Amber’s patience and understanding as we went through our process. Obviously, I am not well versed in the world of insurance. Amber Presiozi made the whole ordeal seem so easy! Her knowledge and expertise was closer to that of a trusted advisor more so than your typical insurance agent. I’m lucky to have her and my new policy for me and my family. If you ever have the opportunity to work with her you should consider yourself lucky!! Amber thank you again so much! Looking forward to continue to work with you in the future.

Caroline Cowden was great to work with. She listened to me and helped me through all my uncertainties. The rates were good as well! I will definitely be back for my additional insurance needs.

I worked with Caroline Cowden to get a home and auto insurance quote. She was very knowledgeable and developed a cost comparison spreadsheet. I was shocked when I saw how much I could save if I switched to Comparion. She provided a lot of recommendations and was very helpful in finding the best rate for me. I highly recommend Caroline.

Amber P. has earned my business and trust with proactive, conscientious, service and support. I’ve benefited with great rates, coverage and cheerful customer service!

Caroline Cowden was a pleasure to work with on our auto insurance. We felt we were in good hands, and our switch resulted in significant savings! I’d definitely recommend working with Caroline.

Nothing bad has happened - thankfully. But, I have peace of mind after working with Caroline Cowden on our auto insurance.

My husband and I have been clients of Liberty Mutual for years and we can confidently say that we continue to receive the highest quality service and value. Our agent, Amber Preziosi, is the leading factor in our superior service. Her vast knowledge and customer care makes us feel safely covered with a reliable company. Most recently, Amber expertly guided us through our purchase of a life insurance policy that addressed our needs perfectly. We are grateful that we have an agent that consistently keeps our best interest in mind. We undoubtedly give Amber and Liberty Mutual 5 stars!

I have worked with Amber Preziosi at Comparion for several years. I highly recommend her for insurance needs. She goes above and beyond to understand all of our insurance needs and somehow always comes up with the right cost effective solution to help us obtain the coverage we need.

Bobbi was very helpful in taking our information, explaining all of our coverage and giving us our options. Super friendly, highly recommend.

Bobbi Jo is the best! Extremely knowledgeable, kind and professional. Highly recommend contacting her for any of your needs!

I called Bobbi Jo Steffey and she gave me quotes for our autos, home, business in a very timely manner. She was very professional and cordial when speaking with her.

I worked with Bobbi Jo Smith to get some quotes. If you are looking for a knowledgeable, professional and excellent person to work with she is the one. She works hard to find you the best rate. Thank you!!

I received a quote from Bobbi Jo Steffey and she was extremely knowledgeable & super helpful! Along with being patient with explaining my quote & answering my questions. I couldn’t of asked for a better experience!!

Honestly I am mind blown after reading the reviews. I have had nothing but a great experience. Probably because I have explicitly dealt with Michelle Kamerer. She is beyond effective, efficient and very prompt with responding. I can’t vouch for the rest of the insurance agents but I can for Michelle. She deserves 6 stars.

I absolutely give a huge thank you to one of your agents Bobbi jo Steffey so polite and very knowledgeable so helpful and had answers for me I so appreciate her and all her help I’ll definitely be telling all my friends about her very satisfied

Gabby Devine is an absolute joy to work with...been dealing with her for years... very knowledgeable..she works tirelessly to get me the best rates for home and auto...always in constant communication with me ...always there for me when I need her!!! Gabby thinks of more ways to save me money by asking questions thst I'd never think to ask. She takes absolute great care of her clients... treats us like her family!!!...just love her!!! Thanks for all you do for me Gabby!! Art Troyan

I got a quote from Bobbi Jo Smith. She was very professional and knowledgeable! She was patient with all my questions . I appreciate her looking at different companies for me to be sure I was getting the best rates. Thank you so very much Bobbi for all you did, much appreciated.

Bobbi Jo Steffey was great! She actually listened to what was important to me and the coverage I wanted and put together a great insurance package to meet my needs. She made it easy doing the price shopping for me and even helped cancel my old policy through another carrier and got a refund for me. She couldn't have made it any easier. Much appreciated Bobbi Jo!

I was interested in an insurance quote and Bobbi Jo Steffey was by far the most knowledgeable and professional agent I have ever utilized. She was polite and worked in a timely manner. I definitely would recommend Bobbi Jo for all your insurance needs.

Bobbi Jo made me feel like I was part of the her family I would want her to take care of me again.

Lauren Roush is a great agent! I was so blessed by the way she came alongside my elderly mother to assist her with her needs. If you have insurance needs, she's definitely the one to call!

Michelle Kamerer has been our insurance agent for many years and we couldn’t be happier with her communication and assistance. Her response time to any inquiry we’ve had has been an A+++. She saved us a good bit of money on our policies from what we were paying with our former agent. Thanks Michelle - we appreciate you!

Great experience with Holly Evanov when she set up our life insurance. She was able to give us many different options and answer all of our questions! She was professional and knowledgeable!

Holly Pope is the best! Quick to respond, provided all the details I needed to make a decision. Easy to work with, would definitely recommend!

Amber is my agent and she has never disappointed me! Not only is she friendly and extremely intelligent, she is efficient and has outstanding customer service She provides her advice when asked and is always very quick when responding. I wouldn't want to go anywhere else!

Holly Pope is excellent to work with. Always responds, quick at getting back quotes, handles all questions. Can’t recommend enough to use Holly for all your insurance needs.

Holly is fantastic to work with and an advocate for her clients

Caroline Cowden is the best - patient - kind and knowledgeable

During the over 20 years Andrew Hartman has been my agent. He has made good recommendations and gave me what I asked for in an efficient and professional manner.

Lauren Semelsberger Roush is amazing. She’s always ready with any answer and information. She responds in a timely manner to any questions you may have. Highly recommend!

We have been working with Caroline Cowden. We contacted her because our home and auto insurance kept going up. She asked to see our declaration pages, explained the coverages we had, pointed out ones we didn't need and ones we did need. And she found us a lower rate. We will definitely be recommend her.

Caroline Cowden helped me get a new insurance rate and I'll be leaving my old company of 20 years. She's been really helpful and sweet this whole process. Highly recommend her and their company!

Caroline Cowden reviewed all of our options in the most polite and informative way possible. Def encourage using Caroline for all your Insurance needs!

I have been with liberty mutual and working directly with Amber Preziosi for about 8 years now! She has been so attentive with any questions or concerns I ever have, and has helped family members of mine, last minute. Even a weekend! She and liberty mutual always get me the best prices in the market and offer more than just insurance needs. I highly recommend choosing them as your provider your will not be disappointed!

We have been shopping around for new auto insurance because our monthly premium went up over 100.00! I spoke with Susan Ramsden who was very professional and understood my concerns and she went over and above my expectations to find us a great quote! It’s people like Susan that restore your faith in insurance companies because I’ve always been skeptical! She made me feel very comfortable! Thank you Susan for your expertise!

I recommend Susan Ramsden. She is great! She is very easy to talk to and is extremely helpful. She made buying insurance very easy. She is very knowledgeable and made sure that we got the best rates! Thank you Susan!

Amber Preziosi continually provides us with the most professional and caring experience. Amber helped us save money on our insurance. She also always takes the time to answer our questions and in such a timely manner. I highly recommend Amber Preziosi!

I called to get a quote with Susan ramsden, and she was so knowledgeable! She looked at a bunch of different companies to make sure we were getting the best rates. Thank you so much for your expertise Susan :)

I cannot say enough how great our experience is with Amber Preziosi at Liberty Mutual. It is such a relief to find an agent that you can trust to be honest and find you the best possible rate. She is incredibly responsive, patient, and takes the stress out of all things insurance. I know we have the best and most appropriate home and auto coverage with her expertise!

I've been with Liberty Mutual since I moved back to Pittsburgh in 2019 and couldn't be happier with my experience. Amber Preziosi has gone above and beyond and exceeded every expectation I could have hoped for as it pertains to insurance. I hold both my renters and car with Liberty Mutual and I am always quick to refer friends and family to this particular office. My rates are always affordable and the service is unmatched. I'd give 10 stars if I could!

I have been with Liberty Mutual and a client of Amber Preziosi for 6 years now, and I couldn’t be happier with my service. She is detailed, responsive, and always making sure I’m getting the best rates. Anytime there has been a concern with my home regarding storm damage or a pipe issue, Amber is quickly available to help me. I have multiple policies through Liberty Mutual and am confident I am getting the best deal with the most impeccable service in the Pittsburgh area.

Susan Ramsden for the win!!! I’d never worked with Liberty Mutual before… We have a new driver, and wanted to shop around for insurance. Susan was helpful, knowledgeable, and answered all of my questions.

I honestly do not have the words for how unpleasant of an experience dealing with this company has been for me. My claims agent Rhea Rocks never once called me back or returned a single message. She put my car through the appraisal process, got it totaled (and uninsurable) then they kept threatening to come obtain my car from me, which would have been okay except they denied my claim. So now I am stuck with a totaled car and no compensation even though I was hit on the highway by a liberty mutual customer with a police report to prove it. I hope that no one ever has to deal with her unprofessional, condescending behavior like I did for the last 2 months. I honestly would not wish it on my worst enemy.

My wife and I were with Liberty Mutual for many years. Premiums kept going up and up with no accidents or claims. I sent a letter and the response was basically that I did not complain enough. We thought if we were loyal to them they would be loyal to us. Big mistake. Finally we switched to another company and are paying one third as much.

The service is only as good as the company will allow them. Saying that, I've been a LMI customer for 8 years now. I would not recommend LMI to my dog. I hate LMI because they don't investigate your claims. I've made many claims. The most recent, was a flat tire. I had to wait 100 minutes for the tow, so I changed the flat myself. They still put it down on my record as a claim. I canceled the tow, and they still paid the tow company even tho I didn't get a tow. This company sucks twinkle holes!

Been with Liberty Mutual for many years. Never any issues....very reliable!

Absolutely awful agent customer service.

Easy and convenient. Filed a claim online. Did not raise my monthly payment after my accident as they promise.

Poor payment management system... Can't pay for your policy ahead of schedule... Operating system is atrocious! Customer Service rep hung up on me! Took money out of my account after I had cancelled my policy depriving my family of getting necessary groceries! I will never go back to them and I will never recommend liberty mutual to anyone!

Too many reasons

I would like to take this time to talk about my insurance agent Michelle Kamerer.she has spent three days going over my auto my homeowners and my life insurance and my wife's life insurance and has went above and beyond to get us what we need she is truly a professional and a caring agent and also a godsend. I wish that there were more professional insurance agents out there dedicated to giving the service and quality professionalism that Michelle has given to us she has truly went above and beyond what she hadto help us to financially be able to see how we could work this into our budget. And also to not sell us what we don't need but what we truly do need and at an affordable price that we can afford and keep within within our budget. She is very kind caring and understanding and very polite as well.And very patient she explains things that you don't understand and she is just a very very awesome individual I truly wish to thank Michelle and liberty mutual for the opportunity to work with her and I hope that there are more agents employed by liberty mutual like Michelle. Sincerely Charles G white liberty mutual for life.

Gave me a great offer then didn't listen...tried to cancel my present insurance on there own..good company awful agents...

Did a bundle giving them my car insurance and home owners when we bought our new house. I had been with the same car insurance for 23 years so I was nervous The rate was decent. Once the year was up the renewals came and I nearly choked. The car insurance went up hundreds. I had no accident, no ticket, nothing. When I called I found whoever was my agent was gone. When asked why the heck it went up and so much the customer service person advised me that there were far more accident claims the previous year than expected. I stated I didn't have am accident and she said she knew that but other insurers had. I was flabberghasted. The homeowners also went up hundreds of dollars. I called my previous auto insurance company and immediately switched back. We didn't change the homeowners that year because they billed and received our premium weeks earlier than they should have. Into the next year we looked at our papers and even though the price went up a lot, the coverage was far too low and we were underinsured. This company, I feel, did a low-ball bait and switch. Bring you in with a low rate then hope to slip the higher prices from there on out. This year we switched our homeowners. Only paid a couple dollars more to get the proper coverage. Don't waste your time.

Terrible customer service, I called my agent and asked her to find me coverage & file a claim, she called later in the day & told me to file my own claim & didn't even address if she found me coverage. I'll be canceling my policy . I rate these turds as a neg 25

I would give them 0 stars if possible. The place is a joke and will rob you. I switched to State Farm and now saving 1000's. By the way Harvey Flowers is a fraud! Do not trust this company

I switched a year ago. All was great until I got my new premiums. My auto insurance went up $70 per month. When I called customer service I was told the discounts I was given a year ago no longer exist and my agent was no longer with the company.

Horrible company to deal with. (Rita)Ofcourse no insurance wants to pay out but after noone would help for obvious reasons I had to go elsewhere. Save your time, money, and frustration. This place is a Joke. Id rather be uninsured than go with this Company.

It was an ordinary Wednesday at work and my employer had scheduled a Liberty Mutual rep to come in and convince us that their insurance was way better than our current carriers, and that as current employees of the company, there would be a "group discount." And there was food! So I figure why not get some free eats and hear what they had to say. That's when I met Harvey Flowers, a guy whose sense of humor and personality alone could win you over. Harvey didn't immediately bombard me with costs and coverage statistics, of which I was very appreciative of while noshing away on a sandwich. He asked questions to get to know me, but were probably more motivated by insurance selling. Either way, never once in our conversation then (or later ones) did I feel pressured to switch my insurance. When the time came to get on the computer and get those numbers, I felt as if I had known Harvey for years! I finish fooding and we finally get to the quoting and selling part of the visit. Murphy's Law kicked in and the Liberty Mutual server wouldn't respond. So getting an instant quote was out of the question. I gave Harvey some info and he said he would email me with a quote in a few days. Sure enough, 2 days later I had a quote in my inbox. At this point I was already shopping around for another insurance carrier with the specific intent of combining my home and auto policies. After comparing my current coverage with the other two quotes I had, I made the decision to switch to Liberty Mutual. Signing up was the easy part as the quote beat all others in price and amount of coverage. My homeowner's insurance went down almost $200/year, and for auto I was getting way more coverage and those groovy extras like roadside assist, new car replacement, accident forgiveness, etc for around the same price. I also enrolled in a program that monitors your driving for a few months and there was a discount just for signing up with the potential to earn up to a 30% discount. (I doubt I'll see the full 30% discount, so I'm shooting for 10-15%!) I signed up in April with the policy taking effect May 1. Fast forward to July. I have had to contact Harvey quite a few times since May 1 with various problems and requests for paperwork that come along with changing insurance carriers. EVERY SINGLE TIME Harvey has responded in a timely manner and has helped me resolve every issue! I cannot recommend Liberty Mutual and Harvey Flowers enough! I believe he is currently licensed in PA and working on some other surrounding states. You'd have to check their website to be sure. There are other agents at his office who are licensed in Ohio and West Virginia, and if they are even half as awesome as Harvey, switching will not be a regrettable decision.