Lead Insurance Agent

Comparion Insurance Agent

Insurance Agent

Executive Insurance Agent

Comparion Executive Insurance Agent

On the road, the trail, or even the water, Comparion agents can customize insurance coverage for all your vehicles. You’ll save even more money (and time) when you bundle your vehicle and property policies together.

Every home is unique. Comparion agents will connect you with right homeowners insurance coverage for your needs at an affordable price.

Home

Affordable protection for your stuff is a no-brainer. Comparion agents will easily protect the contents of your apartment with the right coverage.

Renters

Ensure financial security for your family. Comparion agents will work with you with to find the right policy, so your beneficiaries will receive the money they need in a difficult time.

Life

Your pets are your best friends, and they deserve the best protection. Comparion agents will help connect you with a policy so your pets get the best veterinary care available when needed, including preventative wellness options.

Get superior protection for complete peace-of-mind. Comparion agents will connect you with a higher level of liability coverage beyond the limits of a typical auto or home insurance policy.

Umbrella

Wisconsin

<p>Your local Comparion office has licensed agents specializing in auto, home, pet and life insurance. We're committed to helping you find the right coverage for your insurance needs including options from other carriers. Call us today to reach a local agent - or click &quot;Website&quot; above to choose an agent from this office and call them directly.</p>


Madison, WI

We can’t thank you enough for your kind words. Your review means a lot to us and lets us know we’re on the right track!

Patti Cardarelle, is the best insurance agent someone can use. Patti cares so much for all her clients and give the best advise. Referring Patti is easy as you know whoever you refer will be in the best hands possible!! Highly recommend.

Hi Brittanie D, thank you for taking the time to leave Michael such a great compliment.

Michael Ingalls has been excellent to work with! His communication is on point and we thought he was very knowledgeable throughout our entire transaction. I would highly recommend Michael for all of your insurance needs!

Great service, saved me a LOT of money. Thanks Patty!

Hilary, we can’t thank you enough for your kind words. Your review means a lot to us and lets us know we’re on the right track!

We have been extremely impressed with the service and support from Scott and Hannah!  Both are quick to respond when we've had any questions.  Scott worked with us to get great rates and we would highly recommend him as an insurance agent!

Thank you Hannah for taking the time to leave such a great review. We appreciate you recommending our services in your comments and we're happy to hear that you had a wonderful customer experience.

I would highly recommend working with Michael Ingalls. He was efficient and helpful while setting up our Home and Auto policies  making the process painless. He is very responsive and is always helpful with any insurance inquires we have!

Hi Travis, our local sales agents were blown away by your positive experience!  Thank you for sharing.

We had a great experience working with Scott Hinrichs and his team.  Scott was knowledgeable, provided exceptional customer service, and was able to increase our coverage while reducing our annual rates.  Thanks, Scott!

I know Scott will always have my best interest as his top priority and appreciate the expertise he shares.

Hi Kayla W, thank you for taking the time to leave Michael such a great compliment.

Michael is very knowledgeable, makes sure he understands your needs before recommending coverage and is easy to work with, and quick to respond and efficient! It has been a pleasure to work with you!

Hi Kathy S, thanks for your kind words. We look forward to helping you again in the future.

I appreciate all of the work Michael Ingalls does to continue to save us money on our insurance policies   He is professional, knowledgeable, efficient and quick to respond to questions.  I am very satisfied with the quality of coverage and grateful we made the decision to work with Michael and his companies.

Hi Jeff S, thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agent such a great compliment.

Working with Michael Ingalls for our Home and Auto policies was great! Michael was able to answer all of our questions and give us the best policies for our family. I would recommend him to everyone!

Michael Ingalls is the best agent I have ever worked with. He takes the time to answer all my questions promptly and always finds the best possible solutions for our family’s insurance needs. I would recommend him to anyone!

Wow! Thank you. This review made my day. I’m thrilled that you are satisfied with our services.

Great team to work with. Very knowledgeable and quick to provide answers. Definitely recommend this office.

Wow, we were blown away by your positive words. We really appreciate the time you took to write such a detailed review.  Thank you Bridget!

Working with Scott Hinrichs is really great and I have so much confidence in his support. He is always very involved, answers questions super quickly and personalized recommendations based on my needs. He’s the best!

Hi Corey, that's great to hear!  Thank you for sharing this positive review.

Thank you Casey for taking the time to leave our local sales agent such a great compliment.

My agent, Scott Hinrichs, is incredibly helpful whenever I have had any issues. Always making sure that I’m getting the best deals on life, renters and auto insurance.

Hi Aaron, thank you for taking the time to leave us a 5-star review!

Scott Hinrichs is great to work with, highly recommend!

Hi Keith, the local sales agents in this office thank you for your positive review!

Agent I'm working with does a great job looking for deals to save me money and is very friendly.

I’m sorry you had a bad experience with Liberty Mutual’s claims department. Here at Liberty Mutual, we want to make sure we are connecting you with the appropriate teams to best address your concerns and needs. This is a local sales office. If you’d like to speak with a claims specialist, please call 800-225-2467.

BEWARE….We’re not sure who we’re dealing with. We know it’s a liberty Mutual (Not the local guy) rep but the rep could be in France for all we know but they must not have local adjusters. Our vehicle was stolen two weeks ago and since then what expectations they do set are never met, never. It was suppose to have been towed within 48 hours of being assigned a “adjuster”. That never happened. Days later we’re told we can take the car wherever we want (it’s drivable) but the adjuster who’s in France has no idea of that. Car is taken to a shop the estimate is sent to Liberty Mutual that same day. After hearing nothing for days from the rep WE call  them AGAIN he tells us, mind you we know he hasn’t  communicated with the shop, we need to get him pictures. Talked to the shop they confirm they had never heard from Liberty Mutual. We take pictures and upload them to their app.. Once more  crickets till today when we call AGAIN. Our pictures weren’t what he needed, had to be the shop. He said he called the shop already. Again they had never heard from him. He couldn’t tell us who he spoke to. Aaaand everything is a 48 hour delay no matter who might cause the problem. It’s been a disastrous  process with absolutely zero customer service from Liberty Mutual, ZERO. They have contributed absolutely nothing to the process of course having no issues taking our payments every month. TERRIBLE EXPERIENCE!!!!

Thank you for leaving your feedback, we strive incredibly hard here to make every customer experience enjoyable and we’re sorry we’ve not been able to meet your expectations this time.

Liberty Mutual took care of me very well 2 years ago when I had a house fire, and 1/2  of the house was damaged.  They have NOT done well, however, with home insurance on a new home I purchased last week.  They doubled the premium to $2500/year.  Sales rep told me this will not go down for 5 years after filing the house fire claim.  I am shopping for another company to insure my home and auto.

Everyone was very respectful and comforting to the situation at hand. They got everything done in a timely fashion it may have been even faster if it wasn't for me. So Liberty mutual is moving as fast as you can

Thank you for your review, all feedback is important to us and we’re sorry to hear you’ve had such a frustrating experience.

Cannot make the change to my policy. over two hours on hold. Online does not give the option I need to remove the watercraft. Finally agreed to text messages with service fees and still no response. Extremely frustrated at their lack of customer service

We’re sorry to hear of your less-than-satisfactory experience and hope you will accept our sincerest apologies.

Charged me three-four times what progressive charged and trying to pay a bull after I canceled my policy took 2 hours 🙃

We would like to apologize for your experience. We're sorry to hear you were less than satisfied.

This place is a bunch of crooks. I went to cancel my motorcycle policy due to where I live and have made my payment every month and they tell me even if i cancel I have to pay them another 105 to my plan even know I'm not covered anymore.

Thank you for your review. We’re sorry to hear you had a frustrating experience, but we really appreciate you bringing this issue to our attention.

Had one incident while having them for about two years. Now they won't renew cause of that and they using my 2016 incident with a different insurance then. Which they already knew when I signed up and approved. This insurance is a joke. If you have accident or anything you will probably will get kicked off. They advertise that they don't punish you for using your car insurance. That's a lie.

It seems to be a little better than other companies. I don't know what they would be like after an accident. I do think there is some room for improvement though.

90 dollars a month and no access to services. Charged me for an extra month with no logical explanation. I'd give them 0 stars if that were an option. Never got anything they promised!

Thank you for leaving your feedback, we strive incredibly hard here to make every customer experience enjoyable and we’re sorry we were not been able to meet your expectations.

Try paying your insurance in advance and you will have an extra amount due on the due date.

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.

Liberty Mutual is always providing outstanding customer service.  I've gone through the claim process ... amazing (who says that when working on the service end?) ... contacting my rep (Scott Hinrich's ... I attached his picture) ... easy (he actually called me back when he saw I called and didn't even leave a message, talking to their staff who are so courteous and friendly (big call out to Patty and Tanya today who made me laugh when feeling blue).  So nice to work with a company who have people who care!

Better hope one of Liberty Mutual's insured does not cause an accident for you - they play hardball with victims to avoid responsibility.

Liberty Mutual's driver pulled out in front of me when I had the right of way causing an accident. On the police report, their driver claimed he could not see past another vehicle when he pulled into my lane. Their driver was ticketed for "inattentive driving". Liberty Mutual said I should have done all I could to avoid the accident, and because I hit into the middle of the car that obviously their driver had control of the intersection. I guess slamming on your brakes and skidding sideways while your life flashes before your eyes is not good enough for them. You still are 20% responsible.

Called for a quote on Monday morning.  Never heard back from anyone as of Wednesday afternoon.  TERRIBLE customer service.

If it's integrity, honesty, courtesy and general decency you're looking for, you're definitely in the WRONG place.

This is NOT Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance - This is a Liberty Mutual Personal Sales Office. I work in the office and am trying to get this updated but getting things updated on GOOGLE takes time. PLEASE DO NOT SEND LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE MAIL TO THIS LOCATION.

They did a great job handling my claim.  Anytime I have called to ask an insurance question they have provided great insight.  I would highly recommend the agents in this office.

Shockingly bad! We experienced major damage to our home & filed a 4p claim. We were told emergency services would contact us within the hour. That did not happen.we contacted them again at 8:08, 8:53, 9:55, and 10:58pm. Each and every time we were told the same thing. NO ONE CAME. Finally at 11pm, the call center told us that the Emergency Manager could not find any of their contractors to help us, but we were free to find our own help to get thru the night. "Free to find our own help????" Isn't that what Liberty Insurance is supposed to do? This company ranks an F- for essentially abandoning an insured client.

Whatever you do PLEASE STAY AWAY FROM THIS COMPANY! Worse company to ever work with, high prices and continues to charge for a policy that no longer is in effect due to the property being gone.  Unaccommodating and understanding. STAY AWAY I would pay more for a company the RESPECTS their clients.  There is a loop hole in their system to get you to continue to pay for services that are non applicable in your situation.  STAY AWAY AT ALL COSTS

Was in an accident that was probably caused by one of their insured. First they authorized repairs and medical coverage but now are denying fault. Very frustrating

This  company is cheating.  I had home insurance with this company around 7 years ago  yearly 600 $. But they  start  every year 200   $. Reach this year $1208. I don’t have any claim since today without any  reason they making money. I called  today but they discussed my phone 4 times not giving right answers about  premium increase I  advise all to watch this company   Above your policy. Keep away from this company

So far this is the worst insurance company i have ever worked with. I had short and long term disability insurance through Ryder truck here in Madison WI. When I got into an auto accident that wasn't my fault, had a major concussion, four broken ribs anda displaced knee they decided to pay a total of $154.00. This was for being in the hospital three days and out of work for almost 8 weeks. This place is criminal in how they treat there insured. One star is far too much to give them.

We’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!

I hope never to have to need them for anything huge, but my experiences with smaller things so far have been good.  I had some paperwork issue with my bank saying my car wasn't insured when it was,  and LM reps were able to generate what I needed to fix a $3,600 problem. Claims have been handled promptly. We have a very good price and good coverage. Staff has always been very courteous and informative.

Hi Mark, thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agents such a great compliment.  This kind of feedback motivates us to continue exceeding quality standards!

Scott and his team have been extraordinarily helpful in helping me keep my property insured throughout the construction process and has been a huge help in maintaining coverage thereafter. He has made what could be an extremely complex process as simple as possible and is an absolute pleasure to work with!

Thank you for taking the time to leave us such a great compliment. We appreciate you recommending our services in your comments and we're happy to hear that you had a wonderful customer experience.

Michael went out of his way to make sure we had the best deal in order to make sure we moved with confidence and our new home and coverage would take care of us. He ALWAYS communicated back whenever we had questions, even if we had alot:) I have worked with Michael for many years and will continue to do so. 

Hi Matthew, thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agents such a great compliment.

Hi Tonya, that's great to her!  Thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agent such a great compliment.

Comparion Insurance Agency
Middleton, WI

Office address

Our insurance partners

Comparion Insurance AgencyMiddleton, WI

Office address

Our insurance partners

Comparion Insurance Agency
Middleton, WI