Comparion Insurance Agency

Middletown, NY
"Expert insurance advice from a member of your local community"
Local office in Middletown, NY

Our office

90 Crystal Run Rd
Ste 300
Middletown, NY, 10941
Get directions
Hours
Monday:
8:30am - 5:00pm
Tuesday:
8:30am - 5:00pm
Wednesday:
8:30am - 5:00pm
Thursday:
8:30am - 5:00pm
Friday:
8:30am - 5:00pm
Saturday:
By appointment only
Sunday:
By appointment only

About our office

At the Comparion office in Middletown, trained local agents can help you find the coverage you need, and the discounts you deserve. Our Middletown office located at 90 Crystal Run is conveniently located to State Route 17 and Interstate 84 (two of the three primary highway systems in the county). Amenities surrounding the building include shopping, restaurants, and hotels. 90 Crystal Run is situated within one hour from Manhattan and only 15 miles from Stewart International Airport.

Since 1997 our office has proudly served Orange and Rockland Counties.

Causes close to our hearts
Our representatives participate in a number of community activities including:

  • Volunteering at the Hudson Valley Food Bank.

  • Supporting local fire departments with the Firemark Award.

Talk to a Comparion Agent Today
Contact a sales representative today to learn more about which auto insurance, home insurance, and life insurance options are best for you and your family.

Quote with an agent

We're ready to offer personalized advice and quotes on auto, home, life, pet, and more.
Start your quote

Our insurance partners

Did you know Comparion agents offer insurance from Liberty Mutual and many other companies? Agents can quote trusted insurance partners with products that cover your family, income and assets like a home, car, boat or jewelry. Our mission is to help you find the right insurance coverage at affordable rates.

Our key partners are listed below. We also offer dozens of other national and regional insurance companies depending on where you live.

  • Safeco Insurance
  • American Modern Insurance
  • Homesite Insurance
  • Nationwide Insurance
  • National General Insurance
  • Protective Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • rli
  • Travelers Insurance

Meet our agents

Our agents are licensed in:

  • Connecticut
  • New Jersey
  • New York
  • Pennsylvania
A home ready to be insured

About Comparion Insurance Agency in Middletown, NY

Local sales agents serving customers in Middletown, NY. We're launching Comparion Insurance Agency: A Liberty Mutual Company to help consumers and small businesses get the expert advice they need to find the right insurance policy. Comparion agents will help you find personalized coverage to fit your budget - offering options from Liberty Mutual and many other national and regional insurance companies.
Learn more about us

Find nearby Comparion locations

View More Locations

Comparion Insurance - Yorktown Heights, NY

2651 Strang Blvd
Ste 120
Yorktown Heights, NY 10598
Smartphone1-914-785-0180

Comparion Insurance - Paramus, NJ

61 South Paramus Road
Ste 520
Paramus, NJ 07652
Smartphone1-201-845-4300

Comparion Insurance - Parsippany, NJ

1 Gatehall Dr
Gatehall Corporate Center I, Ste P009
Parsippany, NJ 07054
Smartphone1-973-539-6080
Google Reviews
4.6 / 5
4.6 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
(55 Reviews)
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 27, 2023
Thank you for the 5 stars, John!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Max goes above and beyond for his customers and has an amazing customer service. 10/10 would recommend him for your insurance needs 😊
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 23, 2023
Hi Brianna, thank you for leaving Max such a positive review!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Best customer service that I had in a long time. Max was great from start to finish really helped me throughout the whole process.
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 5, 2023
Hi Tristan, thanks for your kind words!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I got to work with Mr. Cadet and he made the process so easy and enjoyable for me. Not only did he made me feel comfortable and confident about my and my family’s future and finances but made me really realize how important it is to do this. I should have done this years ago! Thank you !
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 4, 2023
Hi Debora, thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agents such a great compliment.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
My experience with agent Max was great. I’m not well educated on life insurance but he was extremely helpful and took his time to answer every question I had. He was a joy to speak to and would recommend to everyone.
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 4, 2023
Wow, we were blown away by your positive words, Lisbeth. We really appreciate the time you took to write such a detailed review! Thank you!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Max was extremely professional. I had a ton of questions and he was more than helpful, very patient and informative. I highly recommend working with Max if you need insurance. Comparion is great!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 4, 2023
Wow! Thank you, Dym. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
This company is amazing to work with ! They Have always responded thoroughly to all of my questions and or concerns and clarified every aspect of their business . Not only have they been very competitive with adjusting my rates but Max Cadet has been extremely helpful, respectful and reliable in times of need .
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 4, 2023
Hi Alyssa, thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agents such a great compliment!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I have had a few different insurance agents over my 30 years of driving and I will say that Nicole Feichtl is probably the most attentive one I have had. She is always professional and prompt anytime I have a question about my policy. I have recommended her to numerous co-workers and friends. Highly recommended!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Hi Jim, thank you for taking the time to leave us a review!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Julie!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Seamless transaction, thanks for making our insurance needs so simplified!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Sharyn!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Nicole Feichtl did an amazing job. Would recommend her for your insurance needs
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Jason!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
The costumer services as been supurb. I appreciated the attention and professionalism from all agents but specifically from Katrina Lagurtta. She spent lots of time and attention on us and is always super helpful with anything we needed. So glad we decided to switch over to them!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Hi Jessica, thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agents such a great compliment.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Meg!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I’ve had the best experience working with Liberty Mutual. Katrina is so efficient and knowledgable as are the other people that have answered when I needed them for information. I’ve told all my family and friends after using 3 other companies that Liberty is the best and especially the agent Katrina I’ve had the pleasure to work with. I feel safer knowing I’m with Liberty. Thank you for all your patience and good advice!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Wow, we were blown away by your positive words, Frayda. We really appreciate the time you took to write such a detailed review! Thank you!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Our experience with Liberty Mutual especially Katrina LaGrutta. has been nothing short of wonderful. Katrina is extremely knowledgeable. She takes time to listen and she is always helpful and pleasant! We are glad to be with Liberty Mutual and Katrina!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Hi Rachel, thank you for your kind words!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I have been in multiple policyholder with Liberty mutual for a number of years and I’m very pleased with their service
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Hi Ginger, thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agents such a great compliment.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
We have been customers for a few years now. Katrina Graby has been a pleasure to deal with. She is extremely professional, always helpful and very responsive.
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
We can’t thank you enough for your kind words, Toni. Your review means a lot to us and lets us know we’re on the right track!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
There is no comparison, insurance agent Katrina GRABY Lagrutta is the best hands down. Professional, knowledgeable and caring: the trifecta for my insurance needs
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 29, 2022
Hi Peggy, thanks for your kind words!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Very knowledgeable and willing to listen to our concerns. Katrina was so pleasant and helpful. She brought forth options and ideas for our coverage. Thanks Katrina !
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 28, 2022
Thanks for the great review, Ceil!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I had a great experience with questions I needed answers to. Katrina was patient and very informative.
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 28, 2022
Debra, thank you for the feedback and we are glad to hear we were able to help you with your insurance needs!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Frank was very helpful and patient answering questions and making sure I understood everything I needed to know
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 28, 2022
Thank you for the review, James! If you have friends who need insurance, please send them to this outstanding team!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Agent by the name Frank helped me with all my insurance needs answered all my questions and help me pick out a good policy
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 28, 2022
We are glad to hear Frank was able to help with all of your insurance needs!
4 out of 5
4 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Empty
Has great knowledge of what he's talking about. Friendly over the phone and patient
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 28, 2022
Jessie, we appreciate the feedback and that you took the time to leave us a review!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Katrina helped set up life insurance for me and my family that will continue to grow cash value which will be helpful down the line. She was also able rewrite my auto policy and save me money while increasing my benefits.
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 28, 2022
Hey Gabriel, thank you very much for the great review and we are very happy to hear we were able to set you up with a great life insurance policy as well as save you money on your auto insurance. If you have friends who need insurance, please send them to this outstanding team!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I was so impressed after contacting Katrinia Graby LaGrutta with questions about my policy. She is the most knowledgeable insurance agent I’ve ever spoke with. Katrinia took her time to explain the policy and got me a fair quote. I’m changing all my insurance needs to Liberty Mutual.
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 21, 2022
Wow, we were blown away by your positive words, Vivian. We really appreciate the time you took to write such a detailed review! Thank you!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Liberty Mutual has excellent options for all aspects of your life, total game changer! Thanks, Katrina LaGrutta for your great advice!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 21, 2022
Hi Stephanie, thanks for your kind words!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I've had great experience working with Katrina LaGrutta and members of her team for my home, auto, life and pet insurance. I get extra piece of mind knowing I can call a real person and get honest advice on what's best for my needs, or help walk me through a claim with ease.
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 21, 2022
Hi Marissa, thanks for your kind words.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Katrina Graby went above and beyond to help my family!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 21, 2022
Hi Jen, thanks for your kind words!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
The best customer service, Katrina Graby LaGrutta went above and beyond to find the right sized coverage for me as a single home owner. I can not recommend this office enough for their excellent service! Thank you!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 21, 2022
Hi Kelsey, thank you for taking the time to leave our local sales agents such a great compliment.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I have never worked with such a responsive and customer-oriented professional as Katrina LaGrutta. I trust her advice and guidance implicitly!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 21, 2022
Hi Fran, thank you for taking the time to leave us a review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Nicole Feichtl is the best! So responsive, helpful and informative. Highly recommend her
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 1, 2022
Thank you for the great review Lauren!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Nicole Feichtl was my agent I really have nothing but great things to say about her. Working with her was pleasure. She explained everything and she make sure I got the best policy and the best cover. Already recommended her for all my family If it possible i’ll rate her 7 stars Great job Nicole
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 1, 2022
Wow, we were blown away by your positive words, Moe. We really appreciate the time you took to write such a detailed review! Thank you!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I worked with Nicole Thomas Feichtl. She was friendly, knowledgeable, and very accommodating to everything question and need I had. I would highly recommend her!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2022
Hi Sara, thank you for taking the time to leave us a review! We appreciate you recommending our consultation services and we're happy to hear that you had a wonderful customer experience.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Nicole provides excellent customer service. She finds the best rates available.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2022
Thank you, Jane!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I love Nicole!! She has helped me through auto insurance and home insurance! She is available all the time and even gave me her personal cell for when I need to reach her. She explains everything thoroughly and always makes sure I am taken care of and getting the best bang for my buck. Would be lost without Nicole!!!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2022
Wow, we were blown away by your positive words, Colleen. We really appreciate the time you took to write such a detailed review! Thank you!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I just want to leave this here for all to read. Nicole Feichtl has always, and continues to be one phone call away from answering all of my insurance questions. She's always profession and eager to find me the best deal. I highly recommend her to everyone who is in need of any insurance needs. Thank you Nicole Feichtl you have been a blessing.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2022
Thank you for your positive review, Darran! This kind of feedback motivates us to continue exceeding quality standards.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Awesome local office with excellent service. I worked with Nicole Thomas Feichtl and she was able to set me and my family up with everything we need for insurance. Never thought about life insurance but she opened up my eyes to it and the benefits at my age. Highly highly recommend this office and working with Nicole.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2022
Thank you for taking the time to leave us such a great compliment, Bret! We appreciate you recommending our services in your comments and we're happy to hear that you had a wonderful customer experience.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
CIA's Agent Nicole Thomas Feichti has some of the best customer service skills I've seen from an insurance agent in a very long time. Timely response with any silly question I may have had with switching companies. Great work. 10/10 would recommend.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2022
Hi Jonathan, thanks for your kind words.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I had all my insurance needs taken care of without issue by Nicole Feichtl!!! Thank you Nicole.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2022
Thank you, David!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 5, 2021
Thank you for your positive review! This kind of feedback motivates us to continue exceeding quality standards.
1 out of 5
1 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar EmptyStar EmptyStar EmptyStar Empty
Started with liberty mutual at 214.00 dollars month been with them a year now paying 672.00 dollars redicoulous every month they go up they lire you in with low rates and go up every month I’m looking for a new insurance just July was 488 for august jumped up to 672 out of control should be a shamed of them self ripping people off
Response from Comparion Insurance
August 31, 2021
We would like to apologize for your recent experience. We're sorry to hear you were less than satisfied.
1 out of 5
1 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar EmptyStar EmptyStar EmptyStar Empty
Very bad costomer service
1 out of 5
1 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar EmptyStar EmptyStar EmptyStar Empty
Hi my experience with this insurance company do not want to pay out for accident involved in nail salons when they give you bad infection and dirty business. I won't recamended this liberty mutual insurance for anything cause you as a consumer who's paying monthly payment than you have a claim this company does not want to pay for your claim and now you have to sue the insurance company and the owner for not paying the claims!! So much headaches now courts is involved all headaches!! Please don't choose this company no more!! Liberty mutual is stealing your money!!
4 out of 5
4 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Empty
2 out of 5
2 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar EmptyStar EmptyStar Empty
3 out of 5
3 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar EmptyStar Empty
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
All I can say about Liberty mutual insurance is that I enjoy their commercials very much I think they are quite entertaining.but the only reason I was asked for a review is because I happen to drive by it all the time so I have not been in there to give an honest opinion. But I am sure they are lovely people in there and do a fine job
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
3 out of 5
3 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar EmptyStar Empty
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Great local office. Very very nice place. The staff here were so pleasant and helpful. On my way to my local VA hospital and stopped in for new insurance ID cards, not my broker but they were so helpful. Thanks liberty mutual, great staff.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
They processed a claim and it was in a timely manner . I was in constant contact and was explained the whole process through. They directed me every step of the way on my claim . A lot of paperwork but that was to be expected. Liberty went above and beyond to process quickly and I was satisfied with their services . I highly recommend them if you need insurance .
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Ask for John Swain
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
4 out of 5
4 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Empty
Katrina is great and she was able to assist me as much as she could.
Write a Review
Comparion Reviews
5 / 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
(1 Reviews)
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Liberty mutual group provides excellent insurance service. I have had all my insurance with them, and my agent worked and keeps working with in a very professional way. He gave me quotes with different options, sent me certificates to my work place, and also made adjustments to my policy promptly. Excellent.
Write a Review
©2023 Comparion Insurance Agency, A Liberty Mutual Company - 175 Berkeley Street, Boston, MA 02116. The materials herein are for informational purposes only. All statements made are subject to provisions, exclusions, conditions, and limitations of the applicable insurance policy. Coverages and features not available in all states. Eligibility is subject to meeting applicable underwriting criteria. Learn more about our privacy policy at libertymutual.com/privacy.
Comparion is an Equal Opportunity Employer and an Equal Housing Insurer.