Cindy Baxter, Insurance Agent | Liberty Mutual

Cindy Baxter

Comparion Lead Insurance Agent
BINGHAMTON, NY

"Expert insurance advice from a member of your local community"

My office

200 Plaza Dr
Ste 100
Vestal, NY 13850
Get directions
Book an appointment with me

About me

As your local Comparion licensed agent, I am committed to helping you find the right coverage for your insurance needs including options from Liberty Mutual or other companies if needed. Call me today so I can help you with auto, home, pet or life insurance.

Follow me

Licensed in:

  • New York
  • Pennsylvania
  • North Carolina

Services:

  • Local insurance agent
  • Insurance agency
  • Insurance consultant
  • Insurance expert
  • Insurance coverage
  • Asset protection
  • Life insurance agent
  • Life insurance consultant
  • Annuity consultant
  • 401k consultant

Hours

Monday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Tuesday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Wednesday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Thursday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Friday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Saturday:
8:00am - 8:00pm
Sunday:
11:00am - 5:00pm

Quote with Cindy Baxter

We're ready to offer personalized advice on your auto, home, life, or pet insurance needs.
Start your quote

Get claims help

File or manage your claim 24/7
Visit the Claims Center
Google Reviews
5 / 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
(120 Reviews)
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I enjoy working with Cindy and will continue to do so in the future. She was friendly, courteous,and professional, through the whole process. She understood my insurance needs and returned a very reasonable quote. She remained patient with me during an unexpected delay on my part and returned my phone calls, texts, and emails, in a very timely manner. Cindy genuinely enjoys what she does and works diligently to maintain a working relationship with her clients . She was very thorough from beginning to end. Thanks Cindy!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 30, 2023
Hi, David! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
It was a pleasure working with Cindy, she did all the leg work and saved me a bunch of money. Happy with my experience
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 27, 2023
Corey, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is the best insurance agent I have worked with. She diligently helped me dig into why insurance premiums have gone up this year and what I can do to lower them. She also helped identify and remove one void /invalid claim from the system which will help with the premiums. Very timely responses and her knowledge about insurance is very helpful and beneficial to clients. Now I know I have someone who I can fully trust with my insurance needs whether it’s new purchase or existing policies. Yes! She takes care of client even if it’s not a new business!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 27, 2023
Jenny, thank you for your review. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I've worked with Cindy through different insurance companies and have found her extremely helpful, timely and professional.
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 27, 2023
Hi, Janine! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Fantastic agent. Has always exceeded my expectations taking care of my Family needs!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 27, 2023
Thank you, Mark!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 27, 2023
Thank you for the 5 stars, Michael!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy was great! Within a day, she helped me find the best quote for a car insurance policy, got me set up, and I was ready to go! As a person who’s new to all of this stuff, insurance can be scary. She made the process painless and easy. She answered all of my questions in a timely manner. Shes good at what she does!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 27, 2023
Camille, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy was the best! I had a few set backs getting my car, but whenever I needed her she was available. Weekends, after work hours etc. she helped me through the whole process!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 16, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Jonny. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Excellent service.
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 12, 2022
Thank you, Kyle!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is amazing! She will go over and beyond to make sure you, your family, have the best coverage! Cindy doesn't just sell you a policy, she becomes a close friend.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Michelle. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is a very helpful and responsive insurance agent!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 29, 2022
Jack, thank you for your review. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy analyzed my policies and saved me out of pocket cost with even better coverage. Excellent service!!!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 17, 2022
Hi, Dan! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
As always, Cindy Baxter totally exceeds my expectations. She is always thorough and prompt completing anything that I ask of her.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 9, 2022
Debra, we are so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 2, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Tahtyanna!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Very friendly, always helpful. Her customers really do come first for her. It was a joy working with Cindy. I'm still using her for all my insurance needs
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 21, 2022
Victoria, thank you for your review. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 20, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Renee!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is amazing, fast, understanding, and goes well beyond what anyone can expect.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 23, 2022
This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Great service! Went above and beyond! Thank you so much
Response from Comparion Insurance
August 29, 2022
Thank you, MP fishing!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy was very helpful and professional. She took time to search for discounts on our current premiums and was able to find savings on our policy. She took all of the relevant information and got back to us the same day. I highly recommend!
Response from Comparion Insurance
August 16, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Amy Furminger. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Very informative and helpful. Made sure I had the best coverage possible. Friendly, efficient, and very professional.
Response from Comparion Insurance
August 8, 2022
Hi Sue Mertens, thanks for leaving such a positive review!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been our agent since 2016 and has provided us with excellent service. We have our auto, home and umbrella coverage through Liberty Mutual. Whenever there are questions or concerns she promptly and efficiently responds with the best possible answers/options. We recently changed residences and all of our insurance needs were resolved within days. I highly recommend her as an agent.
Response from Comparion Insurance
February 6, 2023
Thank you for the 5 Starts and the kind words Jim!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy found us better coverage at a better rate. She seems to stay on top of things.
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 28, 2022
Hi Al Lewis, that's great to hear!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 28, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Dayana Santos!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy was and is awesome saved me a lot of money
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 13, 2022
Hi Michael Eggleston, that's great to hear!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 13, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Megan Mahoney!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I've had Cindy as an agent for as long as I've had insurance, and I would never even think to look elsewhere!
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 28, 2022
Thank you, Triggahappy64. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is very helpful and efficient in guiding me to get my auto insurance. I would like to work with her. She is an excellent agent!!
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 24, 2022
Hi Huanxin Liu, thanks for leaving such a positive review!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy's been really helpful to me when I needed it the most. She's a great insurance agent and she would definitely get someone the lowest rates possible. It feels good working with an agent who cares, because that's rare. Thank you so much and I hope the best for you Cindy!
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 24, 2022
Hi, Sandeep Dash! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 23, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, James Manwaring!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Always very helpful with any issues and finding us the best rates, thank you!
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 23, 2022
Hi Yzr, thanks for leaving such a positive review!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Fast, friendly, thorough. Thank you!
Response from Comparion Insurance
May 10, 2022
Thank you, Ron Harris!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy was very professional and helpful answering all my questions and putting me at ease with any concerns. Definitely would recommend her!!
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 17, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Jackson. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Very good.
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 16, 2022
Thank you, Eric!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy was extremely helpful with arranging an addition to our existing policy. We are now saving quite a bit of money. We are very happy to be working with Cindy!
Response from Comparion Insurance
February 22, 2022
Morgan, we are so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Working with Cindy was a great experience. She had great numbers for switching auto policies. She was very knowledgeable about her product and very quick to respond to my questions. I will definitely do business with her in the near future for my Homeowners policy!
Response from Comparion Insurance
February 22, 2022
We’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is absolutely the best to work with. The process is painless. She is professional, stays on top of things and takes good care of her clients.
Response from Comparion Insurance
February 21, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Alicia. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy always finds the best options available for my car insurance. She is very helpful and knowledgeable.
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 31, 2022
Hi, Christina! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 31, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Yifan Fu!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I found working with Cindy Baxter in getting my insurance quotes and policies was very easy and rewarding. She worked diligently to get me the best prices for the policies I needed. All her communications were very easy to understand and her responses to my questions were prompt and professional. I would not hesitate to recommend Cindy to anyone who is looking to purchase auto and home related insurance.
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 31, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, David. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is a pleasure to do business with! She is very knowledgeable about insurance coverages and always has an immediate response for any questions or needs that we have with our policies. If you are looking for new coverage or even just curious about your current policies, I highly recommend that you give Cindy an opportunity to earn your business!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 26, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Jodie. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 21, 2022
Thank you, Robert H Schwab!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy took care of everything for me. Talk about painless! Thank you Cindy!!!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 18, 2022
Theresa, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been the agent for our home owners and auto insurance for about 4 years. We've been insured by many companies and agents in our lifetime and she is easily the most responsive and helpful we've had. We highly recommend her.
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 18, 2022
We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the work we put in every day. Thanks for your kind words, Dave!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy Baxter provides excellent, professional, efficient and responsive service. She is patient with questions and explanations and a pleasure to have as a representative. Cindy goes the extra mile...ABOVE AND BEYOND!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 4, 2022
Hi, Kim! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 9, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Tanya!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Agent Cindy Baxter did a great job of assisting me to remove the insurance on our sold house after the closing and obtain a new policy on our new house. A real pleasure to work with!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 3, 2021
Thank you, John. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is very knowledgeable and thoroughly explained each question I had about the policies she was offering to me. She was prompt with responses and helped save me money.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 30, 2021
Hi, Mckenzie! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy Baxter has been extremely responsive and professional in all my dealings with her. Without any prompting on my part, Cindy realized I could save a ton of money by combining my auto insurance with my home owners. She reached out to me and laid out the savings. Since I was not too quick on the uptake, she reminded me a couple times until it finally sunk in. Her attempts to save me money were totally unexpected but greatly appreciated. Cindy does her job very well. Thanks Cindy!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 24, 2021
Joe, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Always super helpful and anything I need is always taken care of quickly. Thanks!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 23, 2021
Thank you, Chris Neville!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy Baxter has been our Insurance Agent for many years. No matter what our questions might be, she would respond quickly with all the information we needed concerning either our homeowners insurance or automobile insurance. I highly recommend her for anyone's insurance needs.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 22, 2021
Thank you, Maria. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is very professional and responds in a very timely manner to any inquiry. I appreciate her work on my behalf to present the best price for comprehensive policies to meet my needs.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 22, 2021
Thank you, Marilyn!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 22, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Joe!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 22, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been our agent for years, and she is absolutely wonderful! She is knowledgeable, professional, easy to speak to, and she is there for us. I give her 100%, and I would highly recommend her!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 22, 2021
Thank you, Paul. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 22, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Amanda!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
My family has worked with Cindy for many years and have always had impeccable service and support. She is always quick to respond if we have a simple policy change or question, want to set up a new policy, or have a claim. I couldn't recommend Cindy more.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 19, 2021
Thank you, Daniel. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been very helpful with all our insurance needs. She even helped us with getting pet insurance which has been very valuable.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 19, 2021
Marge, thank you for your review. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy always quick to respond and takes care of our needs. Very promptly Highly recommended
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 19, 2021
Thank you, Dan!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has always been so on top of every concern and need I have regarding my automotive insurance. I’m so glad to have someone who is so attentive and organized handling such important business for me. I’ve gone through her for over 2 years now for every insurance need I’ve had and she’s been nothing short of wonderful and I look forward to continuing doing business with her in the future. 12/10 recommend her for all insurance needs!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 18, 2021
Hi, Emily! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 18, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Sherry!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy saved me $400 a year over Erie. Very professional and is always ready to make changes for. She does a lot more than she has to for clients because she loves her job. A+ Insurance agent
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 18, 2021
Thank you for your review, Scott. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is readily available for all my questions and is very pleasant to work with!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 17, 2021
Thank you, Marissa. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
It has been great working with Cindy. She was referred to me by my job 6years ago and ever since it’s been great. She gets me the best price, response quickly to my call, text and email . Cindy is great. Thank you Cindy.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 17, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Adaoma!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I'm pleased to recommend Cindy for your insurance needs. She is always professional, responsive and helpful.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 17, 2021
Thank you, Patrick!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 17, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Kay!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy was great to work with. She is always responsive, even after 5 plus years.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 17, 2021
Thank you, Andrei!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 16, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Adam!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is responsive in a timely manner, knowledgeable, friendly and helpful. We've used her for years to bundle home, auto and boat insurance!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 16, 2021
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Keri. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I’ve been with Liberty Mutual for a number of years and have always had excellent service.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Thank you, Carl!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I have been a customer of Cindy's for several years, and have personally experienced that she does go out of her way to find the best, and most affordable coverage possible, to fit my budget. Thank you, Cindy!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Thank you for your review, Felicia. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Working with Cindy Baxter is a pleasure. She is resourceful, responsive and always willing to help save me money. I have worked with Cindy for years and would highly recommend her to anyone! She is the best!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Hi, Lisa! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy's help with my home insurance was great.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Thank you for your review, Kenold. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Anthony!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I absolutely love Cindy! She was referred to me, I went to her asking for help lowering my car insurance and BOOM. She got me down from $420 to $280 in like,, an hour!! She got back to me right away, and was just so good with answering all my questions. She really was looking for out for MY best interest and trying to get the best insurance for me. Absolutely loved working with her.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Thank you, Becky. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Excellent response when we had basement damage resulting from 2011 flooding. Cindy Baxter has always been very helpful with any questions I may have had about either auto or homeowner insurance.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Hi, Tom! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Thank you, Keith!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I just signed up for home ins. Cindy was very helpful with us. She knows her job and was very professional and a good value. Thanks for your help Debbie R.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Debbie, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Alessandra!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has always been quick and reliable with my insurances and always found me the best rates and helped save money! She is efficient enough where you don't even need to talk to her over the phone You can just send emails or text messages back and forth and she will get the job done!!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 15, 2021
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Michael. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is a excellent insurance agent. She is always trying to find you the best deals too save you money with the same coverage. I highly recommend her!!
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 28, 2021
Thank you, Jason Eldred. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Very professional, fantastic communication. Highly recommend.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 27, 2021
Thank you, Joe Vaughan!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has helped me in more ways than one. If anyone thinks they are stuck with what they have; they're wrong. Best experience I've had with a professional insurance company ever.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 27, 2021
Thank you, Thomas Beebe-wurzer. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 27, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Tim Rappold!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy B was helpful in obtaining the home insurance, was patient to explain the details of the insurance quote.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 27, 2021
Thank you, Sunil Prasad!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Anytime I have needed anything from Cindy she has followed through and has gotten my family exactly what we needed. She is very responsive and attentive to our needs. She is a pleasure to deal with and will always have our business. Thank you Cindy!
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 27, 2021
Hi, Ryan Diver! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Have been a client of Cindys for 5 or 6 years, Any time i call for help, she goes out of her way to take care of me, and my kids ! Couldnt be more happy with the service, and customer care she provides .. Thank you
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 25, 2021
Chad Martin, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been our agent for years and has always done a great job. Highly recommended!
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 22, 2021
Thank you, Peter Fabian!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been part of our liberty mutual team for 10+ years. Cindy has always been helpful, supportive, and most of all knowledgeable during every life event we have had. Whether it was a life insurance policy or a home owner’s claim, Cindy knew exactly what to do and how to support our family’s needs along the way. I trust Cindy so much with my family that she is now my elderly mother’s insurance agent. If you need a trustworthy agent, Cindy is the agent for you.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 21, 2021
Thank you, Alana Ackley. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 21, 2021
Thank you, Brian Ackley!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 19, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Zachary Swift!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 17, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Brianna Sheriff!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
We needed a new insurance policy quick and affordable and Cindy was able to get us set up and ready to go. She was very professional, polite and easy to work with. We will definitely be switching our other cars onto this plan!
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 17, 2021
Laura Watson, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Amazing to work with she always is helping me find the cheapest prices and always responds fast to my messages !
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 17, 2021
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Amanda Forestier. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Having moved and needing to change my insurance C cindy was so patiet and helpful to me in answering my questions Her knowledge and guidance are exceptional. Thank you Cindy. Rose phillips
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 11, 2021
Richard Phillips, we are so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
My experience with Cindy Baxter was helpful, pleasant and free of any complications! She made my experience stress free and enjoyable!
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 8, 2021
Chuck, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is very professional and responds quickly whenever you need something!
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 8, 2021
Thank you, Hillary Warner!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I have nothing but great things to say about Cindy. She is so prompt, knowledgeable, and helpful! Prices are highly competitive, and service is highly responsive. Strongly recommend.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 4, 2021
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Karen Kim. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is very professional and responds quickly whenever a need arises.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 30, 2021
Denise Ferro, thank you for your review. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Love working with Cindy! Very knowledgeable, professional and quick to respond. Would recommend to all of my friends & family!
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 28, 2021
Thank you, Jennifer Chase. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 28, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Susan Dean!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 24, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Patricia Baxter!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Been with Liberty Mutual for over 30 years. If you are bundled with home and auto, the rates are great and hard to beat. With that said, everyone's situation is different. Cindy Baxter has been most helpful to me and understanding of my issues and needs. Completing them in short time with professionalism. If calling Liberty Mutual for insurance needs, be sure to ask for Cindy Baxter.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 22, 2021
Hi, Joe Celelli! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 21, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Susan Jeavons!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy Baxter has been my insurance agent for several years. She has always been responsive to any questions I may have, and has always gotten me the best rates available.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 21, 2021
Donna Bechtel, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 21, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Anthony Cagle!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is an amazing agent that has helped us save money and find the best policy matches to fit our needs. Whenever we have a question or problem, she is very responsive and takes the time to look at all of our available options. When we purchased our classic vehicle, we turned to Cindy to help us find a policy that would cover us. She always answers all our questions, and has always been friendly and professional. I have recommended her to many of my friends and family, and they have all been impressed with her service.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 20, 2021
Thank you, Tracy Allen!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy went above and beyond what I was expecting. I had called the main number to Liberty Mutual only to tell someone about the volume of letters I was getting from Liberty Mutual. Cindy answered and explained that because I had used Everquote like 6 months ago, they kept requesting quotes. Do not ever use Everquote use an agent like Cindy. While she had me on the phone she asked if I would like for her to search around to see if she could find me a better price than what I was currently paying. She followed through and really did get me a better quote. The coverage was for more than what I had with Geico and the price was substantially less. She answered all of my questions quickly and thoroughly. I never had to wait for her to get back to me either through email or the phone. Not only did she call me after 5:00 on a Friday but she answered an email on Saturday! She is driven, reliable and quite friendly. I highly recommend that you call Cindy for your insurance needs.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 20, 2021
Kathi Ellis, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
After our son got his own car insurance policy Cindy went out of her way to review the policy after he dealt with a different insurance agent. She found that he had been signed up for rental insurance when he didn't need it and had another driver on his policy which was not accurate. She saved him money on his policy but going above and beyond.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 20, 2021
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Kelly Nannery. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Very helpful and always there when you need her.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 20, 2021
Thank you, AJ Thakral!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is a great insurance agent. Very fast and helpful and finds the best quotes.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 20, 2021
Lauria Converse, thank you for your review. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been my insurance agent for several years and always makes sure I’m protect with my auto, home and life insurance needs. She is extremely knowledgeable and professional. I know she has mine and my family’s best interest in mind.
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 20, 2021
Brenna Furgeson, thank you for your review. We appreciate your business! Thank you, Brenna Furgeson. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 20, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Mohammad Younis!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
September 20, 2021
Thank you, Jay Booker!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I have worked with Cindy for a good number of years now and have always found her to be both knowledgeable and professional. Not only does she offer top of the line products but she is always looking out for our best interests when it comes to coverage and affordability. I would highly recommend Cindy Baxter to anyone with insurance needs.
Response from Comparion Insurance
August 13, 2021
Hi, Douglas Lukasik! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is a terrific LM representative-always answers our calls and questions as well as reviews our policies for what we need-highly recommend her!
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 11, 2021
S Fox, we are so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 29, 2021
Thank you, Sean Walsh!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 22, 2021
Thank you, Alicia Meagley!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
I have been with Liberty Mutual for many years and insure my auto and home with them. My special thanks to Cindy Baxter for always being so helpful when discussing my options and answering any questions I might have.
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 18, 2021
Thank you for the 5 stars, Norma Melendez!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy Baxter always keeps me updated on any changes and always finds me the best deals love doing business with her
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 18, 2021
We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the work we put in every day. Thanks for your kind words, Damon Kintner!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy Baxter has been handling our home and auto insurance for many years. She is very quick with response time and is always willing to look for better policy options when asked. I like having a local person to contact and Cindy is always available. We have better coverage, with lower rates, through Cindy and Liberty Mutual than we have had with other companies.
Response from Comparion Insurance
June 18, 2021
Thank you, Jill Bennedum!
Write a Review
Comparion Reviews
5 / 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
(23 Reviews)
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy Baxter, my insurance agent-has always been very dependable & punctual with all my insurance needs. I definitely recommend her, a 5 star agent!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 27, 2023
Thank you, Kevin. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Agents I had previously had left and I wanted/needed a local person to speak to because of an issue with my car and Cindy promptly returned my call/email and helped me handle things. Then when my situation changed again, I was able to get help from Cindy again. Her help with my car insurance needs was greatly appreciated.
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 5, 2022
Dawn, we’re so glad you had a good experience. We look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is a true professional insurance agent! she always goes the extra mile to get her customers the best possible rates.
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 16, 2022
Thank you, Sid. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Timely and efficient service provided and accurate quotes given. Plus, helped expedite change of car insurance with a very short deadline.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 21, 2022
Hi, D,N! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has always given excellent service and is very responsive to all request. She will look for the best price for the coverage you are looking for and explain what the various options offer.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 13, 2022
Hi, Eric! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Knowledgeable and available. Always there when I needed her
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 12, 2022
Thank you, Michael!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy really knows her products and is true pleasure to work with.
Response from Comparion Insurance
August 29, 2022
Thank you, Tom D!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Great customer service
Response from Comparion Insurance
July 29, 2022
Hi Zachery Buresch, that's great to hear!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Great service and follow-up. Thank you!
Response from Comparion Insurance
May 17, 2022
Thank you, Marcie!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
A ok
Response from Comparion Insurance
March 16, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Eric!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is always so quick to get us an answer and makes sure to explain everything thorough. She has always been so helpful with our car and home owners insurance. We also went through her for our life insurance.
Response from Comparion Insurance
February 21, 2022
Tara, thank you for your review. We appreciate your business!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy was prompt in returning our calls. She took the time to explain every thing and answered our questions. Was good working with her.
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 25, 2022
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Sally. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Hours before closing on our new home, the mortgage company informed us that we needed to pay our revised homeowners insurance in advance. Cindy Baxter returned our frantic phone message within minutes, calmly and efficiently processing our payment and providing our lawyer’s office with required information. Months later, as our daughter was closing on her first home, Cindy again was immediately responsive, reassuring, and efficient. Again, she responded to the message within moments! She remembered details of our family’s policies and associated changes throughout this year, and made sure everything was in order. We appreciate Cindy’s services very much!
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 18, 2022
We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the work we put in every day. Thanks for your kind words, Alison!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Great customer service
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 18, 2022
Thank you, Jarrod!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
incredible customer service and kindness
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 18, 2022
Thank you for the 5 stars, Dianna!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Great working with her. Attentive to my needs and very helpful in finding me the best deal for my son’s auto insurance.
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 18, 2022
Thank you, Steve!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
fast and excellent
Response from Comparion Insurance
January 18, 2022
Thank you, Mike!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is always there to help you in any way she can. I have been with her for a few years now and am always satisfied with her service.
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 15, 2021
Thank you, Valerie!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been my agent for many years. I can always trust her advice and knowledge. I feel completely confident that should anything ever happen I can count on Cindy to help!
Response from Comparion Insurance
December 6, 2021
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Kim. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy is a true professional Insurance Agent; always there when you need Insurance advice!
Response from Comparion Insurance
November 16, 2021
Thank you, Saeid. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Always available for questions with professional & knowledgeable responses. Knows her products well.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 28, 2021
I’m so grateful for your kind words, Ted B.. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Cindy has been our agent since switching to Liberty Mutual 3 years ago. Very friendly and helpful with any questions we have.Promptly returns calls and emails.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 28, 2021
Thank you, JL W.. This review made our day!
5 out of 5
5 out of 5 starsStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar FilledStar Filled
Excellent, helpful, very responsive and pays attention to details.
Response from Comparion Insurance
October 28, 2021
Thank you, Frank R.!
Write a Review

Our insurance partners

Did you know Comparion agents offer insurance from Liberty Mutual and many other companies? Agents can quote trusted insurance partners with products that cover your family, income and assets like a home, car, boat or jewelry. Our mission is to help you find the right insurance coverage at affordable rates.

Our key partners are listed below. We also offer dozens of other national and regional insurance companies depending on where you live.

  • Safeco Insurance
  • American Modern Insurance
  • Homesite Insurance
  • Nationwide Insurance
  • National General Insurance
  • Protective Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • rli
  • Travelers Insurance

Frequently asked questions

About Comparion Insurance Agency in Vestal, NY

Local sales agents serving customers in Vestal, NY. We're launching Comparion Insurance Agency: A Liberty Mutual Company to help consumers and small businesses get the expert advice they need to find the right insurance policy. Comparion agents will help you find personalized coverage to fit your budget - offering options from Liberty Mutual and many other national and regional insurance companies.
Learn more about us
©2023 Comparion Insurance Agency, A Liberty Mutual Company - 175 Berkeley Street, Boston, MA 02116. The materials herein are for informational purposes only. All statements made are subject to provisions, exclusions, conditions, and limitations of the applicable insurance policy. Coverages and features not available in all states. Eligibility is subject to meeting applicable underwriting criteria. Learn more about our privacy policy at libertymutual.com/privacy.
Comparion is an Equal Opportunity Employer and an Equal Housing Insurer.