Wisconsin

Sales Associate

Liberty Leaders

Pacesetter

Appleton, WI

Online

Midwest Region Virtual Agents

Senior Agent

Comparion Lead Insurance Agent

Your local Comparion agents offer expert assistance to get the right vehicle coverage that fits your needs and budget, no matter what you're driving.

Vehicle

Whether you rent or own, protect your home and belongings from damage or loss by talking to a local Comparion agent today.

Property

The things that are the most important to us require the best protection. Rest easy with the right life insurance and other specialty coverage.

Life and other

Five stars for finding us great rates and saving us over $700 a year on our policies!

Tony was quick, efficient, friendly and saved us money! 100% would recommend Tony Mollica!

Working with Tony was quick and seamless. He took care of everything and was EXTREMELY thorough in every explanation and was able to answer all of my questions!

Tony was incredibly prompt, knowledgeable, and helpful throughout the whole process. I can't recommend him highly enough. I definitely feel better knowing if I ever need anything that it will be handled quickly and professionally!

Tony was a pleasure to work with. He is prompt, and explains everything so you understand. I highly recommend his business!!

Working with Tony Mollica is always an exceptional experience from start to finish. No matter what insurance-related questions or needs we have had, Tony has always been incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful. He consistently takes the time to find the best coverage at the best possible price without sacrificing quality or service. What really stands out is how much he cares about making sure everything is explained clearly and handled smoothly, which brings a great sense of confidence and peace of mind. It is rare to find someone who combines professionalism, honesty, and outstanding customer service the way Tony does, and we truly appreciate everything he has done for us. Thank you for allowing  us to breathe a little easier! - Ben & Jess

Tony was awesome I wasn’t sure on what I wanted for my policy and how much to insure so I was in a great position in case of accident. Talked and walked me through everything. Was a great experience

Tony was awesome to work with! My wife and I found Tony via a referral while purchasing our first home. He answered the first call and obtained all necessary information on it, had us a quote back very quickly that fit our situation. Being new to Home Insurance, he walked through the policies in great detail with us to ensure we understood all coverages/coverage options and that we had no doubts. He never did push any coverages that seemed excessive or unecessary and was factual with his overviews. We came from a larger competing broker, who has never given us cause to leave, but Tony’s fast and informative service won us over. Highly recommend!

Tony made my job figuring out my car insurance set up so much easier and was very helpful! Also gave me the best options that’s available!

Amazing service. Tony is quick with responses and really cares about getting you the best rates. Highly recommend!!

Tony was great! Took the time to explain each coverage option and the pros and cons. Made it easy to understand, which made it an easy yes! Saved me over $300/year. Definitely would recommend!!

Great guy to work with. Thorough when going through you policies.  Very professional.

I moved from State Farm to Integrity after Comparion was able to find me over $600 in savings. Nathan, Tony, and the team are great to work; they communicated well, followed-up multiple times, and prioritized my understanding of the process and the differences between insurances. I will absolutely be working with them again.

Top notch service from Tony! Tony was responsive, transparent, and took the time to walk through my policy options in detail.

Tony is great. Takes care of all my insurance needs and goes the extra to check out multiple insurance companies to make sure I have the best insurance for my needs.  Great Work!

Very pleased with the service we received.  Tony was very responsive to questions, returning calls in a very timely manner.

Tony and his team are always responsive to any request I have. They take care of all my insurance needs; home, auto, umbrella, atv and camper.Tony has been my agent for several years.He has always kept me posted on the best options and rates for my insurance needs.

Most importantly, he has made sure that I get claims responded to quickly and without any hassles. I highly recommend Tony and his group. They do an awesome job!

Todd R, Chetek WI

Tony is a wonderful agent and has saved our family hundreds of dollars on multiple occasions! Best insurance agent ever!

Tony saved us $1700 on annual insurance. He was very responsive and thorough. Highly recommend!

Tony helped me get insurance on my camper.  He has been very informative and great to work with.  I would highly recommend him.  Thanks again Tony!

Very responsive, knowledgeable, offers recommendations as needed, and just an all around friendly personality. Highly recommend Tony!!

Tony and team were very helpful in finding us better auto and home policies to fit our needs.  They were quick and answered our questions thoroughly!

Tony is always a pleasure to work with. He was able to meet my auto and home insurance needs and even saved me money along with better coverage. I would strongly recommend Tony!

Great people, so helpful! Willing to do the work to find best rates, I've never had better

Tony is always looking for ways that I can save money in my policy. He was also my first phone call when I had a water damage from a burst pipe. Got the ball rolling right away!

Very informative! They know what they're talking about and they make you you're covered!

Tony and team were great to work with. Took care of all of our needs and gave us valuable insights on alternatives that we never thought of. Highly suggest giving Tony a call!

Tony does a great job searching the market for the most competitive, cost effective, and overall value of insurance!

Tony is always looking out for us to make sure we have the coverage we need at a reasonable price. If there’s a better deal out there, he’ll find it!

Tony is great to work with!! He found us great rates for all of our insurance needs and it's saving us $$$!

I have worked with Tony for a couple of years and he does a great job! He is very responsive and looks out for your best interests.

4 out of 5 because 5 stars makes it look like a bot left the review.  Tony has been awesome to work with! We’re excited to see how he can take care of us for many years to come!  5 stars if you ask me! 

I was extremely happy with my experience with Tony. I have had the same insurance for home and auto for over 14 years and was apprehensive about changing it but had wanted to for years. He took the time to understand me as an individual. Which means he made sure I wasn’t overwhelmed with numbers or questions. He made everything quick and easy which is exactly what I needed as a busy single mom. Thanks Tony!

I’ve been working with Tony Mollica at Comparion Insurance Agency for a while now, and I can honestly say he is one of the most dedicated insurance professionals I’ve ever met. Tony consistently goes above and beyond to ensure I have the right coverage at the best possible rates. He’s always quick to respond, patient in explaining options, and genuinely cares about finding the perfect solution for my needs.

Thanks to my positive experiences, I’ve referred my entire family and close friends to Tony—including my parents, my brothers, and my girlfriend—and every single one of them has been just as impressed. If you’re looking for an insurance agent who truly puts clients first, do yourself a favor and give Tony a call. You won’t be disappointed!

Tony and Valerie kept looking for the best policy for our needs.  Great to work with.

Very friendly and easy to work with. Great rates as well.

Great service and always one step ahead. Great company for your Insurance needs.

Tony is responsive and always willing to help! He saved us money and got us better coverage on our car insurance!

Tony always goes above and beyond to help me with any of my insurance related needs.

Been with Tony for a couple years now. Great guy and always takes good care of my insurance needs.

Great service, really helped us through the process.  Would recommend.

Outstanding service!  Val went above and beyond for us - suggesting a review of our policies, offering to generate comparisons and then thoroughly explaining everything.  Super experience and very much appreciated.  Thank you!

Tony has been top notch in finding the best value insurance needs without compromising coverage.  He's been great to work with personally, and communication is excellent.  Highly recommend!

Tony is on top of his game and always striving to find me the best rates

Tony made the process to find better coverage seamless. So grateful!

Awesome agents they remind u when your insurance is due honestly I would have forgot thank you so much and always checking to make sure you are getting the best price with the best coverage

Tony is the best ! He goes above and beyond what any insurance company has done for me in the past !!! Trust him with all of my insurance needs! 

Tony, makes the whole process easy and simple, while walking you through any questions you might have, I will certainly keep doing business with him.

I had a great experience working with Valerie. She was prompt in her responses and made it super easy for me to get new insurance and even found me cost savings on my current auto insurance. Great service!

Tony was able to find a ton of issues in my previous homeowners policy that could have been drastic.  Along with always taking care of my auto policies!

This team has always taken care of all of my needs! They are fast, informative, communicate extremely well, and have delivered better rates with better coverage! Appreciate them and all their hard work! Shout out to Val and connecting me with the appropriate partners!

Val did a great job. Very quick and effective. Thanks again 

Valerie is GREAT! She finds me a policy whenever I need one!! So helpful and so kind. She always finds the BEST deals!!!!!!!

Valerie is amazing! Easy to work with and personable 

Valerie made it super easy to help me find a new auto insurance policy! She is very responsive and knowledgeable - I had several questions that I always got an answer to quickly. I’m happy I chose to work with Valerie and recommend her to anyone!

Tony was great in helping us switch over our insurances.  He listened to what we were looking for and gave us an array of options that best fit our needs.  5 Stars! Highly recommend!

Honestly - Anthony is the best! Super helpful and sincerely wants to get you good coverage at the best possible price. Would absolutely use their services again!

Great explanation in laymen's terms , professional and easy  to talk with!

Tony made my insurance policies painless. He also made sure that I had the correct coverage needed

Tony is a great agent. He takes the time to listen and answer all questions. He puts forth the effort to find the best deals available.

Tony is extremely helpful and always goes above and beyond to find the best rates for my family. I recommend him to everyone who asks about insurance.

Tony is an excellent insurance agent. Friendly, hardworking and always looking out for the client. He has saved our family a lot of money by shopping for the best policies out there for us.

Great industry knowledge, always responsive, and very courteous.  Tony and team helped us find the best deal on insurance for lots of different scenarios (classic car, adding a teen driver, etc.).

Great customer service and pricing! Tony is quick to respond and does a great job finding what you need!

Tony is always quick to respond to the questions and needs of me and my family. He helped us when we were having issues with our home insurance and was extremely helpful in getting the policy transferred to a new provider!  Highly recommended!

Tony was able to get me better coverage for ALOT less money! Thanks Tony!

I was referred to Tony Mollica and it was the best referral I have ever received.  He was very pleasant to work with and getting the insurance I needed was made fast an easy.  Thanks for such great service.

Tony was patient with all my questions and explained in nonindustry words that I understand.  I received excellent service and pricing I can afford.  I the insurance treats me as well, i will be in good shape.  Recommend highly for customer service.

Fast and easy boat policy. Ended up with more coverage for less money than my previous carrier and the piece of mind that Tony (also being a bass fisherman) will understand any issues that arise with the boat and or equipment.

Tony has been more than helpful eved since I started using his services. He has always gotten me the most affordable rates

Tony is a great agent. He is always so helpful with all of our insurance needs!

Tony was great to work with! He was very respectful of our time & made the transfer of policy information the easiest I’ve ever experienced while maintaining our confidentiality. Thank you for not only saving us money, but also providing us with friendly & knowledgeable service! I’ve recommended Tony to all of my family!

Tony was easily the best insurance person I have ever dealt with. Very professional, efficient, and kind. I would highly recommend him to everyone!

Valerie and the team made moving out of state and into WI a breeze. Got me great rates and made the process seem easy. Would HIGHLY recommend the whole team for any insurance needs.

Valerie and Tony are AWESOME. Super fast, easy to talk to and understand. Works with you to get you exactly what you need.  So happy to have found them and looking forward to a great working relationship.

Tony is SUPER easy to work with.  Responds to email and calls quickly!  Been using him for years and wouldn't go anywhere else!

Very helpful with setting up new insurance for me.

Great service. Great guy. I felt like it was an effortless process. Highly recommend.

Tony really cares about your family, and making sure he’s saving you the most money possible while also making sure you are covered properly!

Tony has been handling our insurance needs for my home and auto for a few years now and it’s been great. Always looking for new coverage or deals, and always prompt responses or answers to any questions. Highly recommend!

Tony is very knowledgeable about insurance needs. He took time to understand our family's needs and get us the best rates available. Tony is very personable and easy to talk with about rates and making changes as needed.

Tony Mollica

Comparion Senior Agent | Appleton, WI

Quote with Anthony

Hours

Location

2323 E Capitol Dr
Ste 400
Appleton, WI 54911

About me

Licensed in

Arkansas - 18376460

Arizona - 18376460

Iowa - 18376460

Illinois - 18376460

Michigan - 18376460

Services

Car insurance

Home insurance

Umbrella insurance

Life insurance

Insurance consulting

Languages

English

Awards & Honors

Liberty Leaders
2022

Pacesetter
2017, 2018, 2018